Feverish thoughts about one of our favourite franchises and the fleeting hopes of their being more games like it.

We've been ill for the past week. This has left a lot of time to be online, and subsequently a lot of it has become dominated by Grand Theft Auto VI, a game we have no intention of purchasing until it is available on PC and at a deep discount.

Because of this, we decided to power on ye olde Xboxe, and finally go through Saints Row (2022)'s final DLC - it was basically the last multiplatform game we bought on console before switching pretty much exclusively to PC.

And that got us thinking about Saints Row as a franchise, how much it means to us, and how I don't know if there's still space for games like it.

our history

Our start with the Saints Row franchise is I suspect the same as a lot of people's - we played GTA4 and were disappointed by the change in tone compared to Vice City and San Andreas. The requests to go bowling. The various forms of ludonarrative dissonance - cutscene Niko constantly complaining about being broke as gameplay Niko had more than could be spent. The more realistic handling on the cars when what we were looking for was arcade action.

And then along came Saints Row 2 - where the developer Volition and THQ made some smart moves to directly position itself against GTA4's changes. And they worked - they were enough to get us hooked on the series and even cause a few personality shifts here and there. [1]

Saints Row: The Third was a regression in some ways, but some of its setpieces remain in our memory to this day. Saints Row IV is one of our favourite sandbox games of all time just by virtue of it being really fun to screw around with superpowers (and is also the first time we can remember seeing a mainstream game acknowledging and encouraging casual sex with friends). We still revisit the How the Saints Saved Christmas DLC every year or so as one of the few traditions we have around the holidays.

Eventually we went back and played Saints Row (2006) beyond the demo, and found it interesting to see how much has progressed in just a couple of years, useful for catching some references and story beats here and there, but not fully essential.

Gat Out of Hell... we need to replay it at some point, but our memory is of a budget game with not as much to do but still, Hell as a location does make for some interesting exploration that wouldn't be possible in a more grounded city.

But once you've been through space and been through the depths of Hell, there's only a few directions that can be gone from there - either you need to explore time, or you need to reboot the whole thing and start over.

And that brings us to...

saints row (2022)

As probably the most controversial game in the franchise, Saints Row (2022) gets a lot of flack. I'm not going to say its a great game. There are a lot of questionable design decisions[2] that have only been partially mitigated in some cases by the patches Volition were able to put out. The writing skews a lot younger. None of the characters you like are around.

But I think it's still worth playing. It is interesting seeing what a more empathetic take on the open world sandbox formula could be, even if that sometimes/often veers into cringe millennial territory (and this is coming from a collection of cringe millennials). The city is substantially more unique as a location than the ones in past games, and the player is incentivized for learning about local history and taking photos of landmarks. We can't speak for the others[3], but the femme British player character voice (Emily O'Ryan) gets some incredible line reads in, particularly when you're not expecting a sentence to be punctuated by "wanker". The overhauled character customization is impressive with the return of SR2's gender slider and the much more granular outfit settings.

But it is also clear about where the wheels were starting to fall off, and unlike Gat out of Hell or Agents of Mayhem, it isn't possible to use the "well, it's just a spin-off" excuse. At least pre-patch, most of the side-missions you could do tended to overstay their welcome a bit - they needed to get as much as they could from every single gameplay addition. There are whole radio stations that are just library music - no 80s pop station with recognizable hits, just pretty generic synthwave.

Even before any accusations of "ruining the franchise" that may have kept some longtime fans away... to be sustainable for this volume of open world, I suspect SR2022 needed to sell a lot more copies than it ever could have done. Had the rumoured SR2 remaster come out, maybe that would have stemmed the bleeding, but we will never know. And so another studio loses itself as the publisher continues to sell what was left behind, never patched again.

But hey...

Saints Row (2022) does absolutely have the nicest paws, even if they're unlocked further in the game than we'd like.
(The landscapes are pretty neat, too.)

the death of the "aa" game

Zooming out for a second, the games industry right now feels like it can only support the biggest of the big or the smallest of the small. The budgets on the biggest games were already overinflated and playing the numbers game, and the smallest now risk being completely drowned out by slop.

For the open world sandbox genre, this has a particular set of knock on impacts. Given the roughly 20 year cycle of nostalgia, we would expect to start seeing indie games not just inspired by the GTA PS2 trilogy, but also Jak 2 (and 3), Spider-Man 2, The Simpsons Hit & Run, Total Overdose/Chilli Con Carnage, Destroy All Humans!, etc.

To my knowledge, these have not really materialized, and I suspect that's because these sandboxes generally need a lot of systems in place - on foot controls, driving controls, pedestrian systems, music licensing, mission design, world design which feels good for both sandbox gameplay and missions. That needs a lot of varied skills, and a solo dev or small team may not have all of them. [4]

At the same time, we are seeing greater consolidation across AAA publishers. Microsoft does not have much reason to make another Crackdown when a new Forza Horizon would be a much easier sell. [5] Ubisoft might make a new Watch Underscore Dogs or Far Cry game eventually, but there is unlikely to be an experiment like Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon. EA will never release anything like The Saboteur again, particularly under the new owners.

We'd be remiss mentioning The Saboteur without thinking about this song.

Perhaps that's part of why we treat SR2022 with just a little more respect than others. It might be one of the last of its kind in general; the last time that level of scope and ambition in a sandbox is attempted without it being a 100% safe bet.

Rest in peace, Volition. I hope everyone who got laid off found work elsewhere, and that IdolNinja is modding cool things into the afterlife.

In the meantime, if we need our sandbox fix, there's always SR2 Archipelago.

footnotes


  1. Along with some of the songs on the 80s station that had never been on our radar before, our favourite colour was red before SR2, and has been purple since. ↩︎

  2. Our particular bugbear is the need to do glory kills for health regen, which breaks the flow of combat when it's something you have to do rather than an occasional treat for hitting the melee button now and then. ↩︎

  3. For the other games, the Saints Row Wiki lists all voice lines for each player character voice, sometimes with an audio clip. For 2022, it doesn't seem to really do that. Funny, that. ↩︎

  4. Or at least, without taking the Faustian bargain of vibecoding some of them, which might make the effort reasonable but will implode at least some, possibly all of their sales immediately. ↩︎

  5. As a reminder, Microsoft's gaming division in particular remains on the BDS boycott list. ↩︎